4.6 from 14 reviews
Leave a Review

You've bought this product 0 times.

You've bought from this vendor 0 times.

New Horizon Farm and Dairy

Milk-Orange Creamsicle

Dairy Products: Grass Fed, Milk

LOCAL MILK delivered to your doorstep from the only approved supplier of Grade-A milk with an IMS Listing! Happy Cows is a creamery located at New Horizon Farm, using local milk from our own farm. Whole milk is bottled and processed right after morning and evening milkings. Our milk averages a 4.2% butterfat from our grass-fed cows. The milk is non-homogenized and minimally processed, using a gentle, low heat pasteurization process that preserves the flavor. Because the milk is non-homogenized, cream will rise to the top. This requires shaking well before drinking or skimming the cream off the top. ** Our milk is stamped with a "Sell By" date, meaning that you should receive your milk before the date stamped on the bottle. If delivered and stored correctly, your milk will be good for 10-14 days past the "Sell By" date**USA / Ohio / Clinton County

Whole milk, dextrose, natural flavor, cornstarch, carrageenan and yellow #6

Sorry, this product is unavailable in your local market at this time. It is available in the following markets:
  • SWO-Thurs
  • SWO-Tues
  • CBUS-Tues
  • You must login or register to ask questions in the product forum.
    Q: How long until the root beer Milk!!! Can't wait

    A: 'We will be making root beer float May through August. So glad that you enjoy it!'

    February 20th, 2024 person_outline Bert C.
    Q: This sounds so good but my Family doesn't eat anything with artificial coloring. Has the company ever thought of making this kind with natural colors instead? Orange Juice Concentrate or Tumeric would produce this orange color. 😁

    A: 'Yes, we are trying different recipes to remove the artificial color. We went through this process with our strawberry milk and we’re quite pleased with the results. '

    January 15th, 2024 person_outline Anna H.
    Q: Are there any other flavors you do (besides chocolate, pb, orange, mocha, strawberry)? Like seasonal flavors or specials?

    A: 'Yes. We will be bringing back RootBeer Float Milk in May. We also have a Cookies and Cream Milk that we process in the winter. In the fall, we have Pumpkin Spice Milk and Egg Nog Milk during the holidays.'

    May 26th, 2023 person_outline Stacie M.
    Q: I love this. Thank uou.

    A: 'So glad that you enjoy it! We love hearing feedback from our customers about our milk!'

    May 23rd, 2023 person_outline Judy B.
    Q: Delicious, a creamsicle. I love creamsicles. I would like to know calorie count, fat, fiber, sugar...... Thank you. I bought the strawberry also. Is all this the same calorie fat fiber sugar.....thank you. Oh my It is VERY good.

    A: 'So glad that you enjoyed the milk! At this time, we are not required by USDA or the FDA to generate nutrition labels for our dairy products, due to the size of our farm creamery. I can certainly provide percentages of ingredients for you, but as for calories, protein, fiber and carbs, we are not equipped to calculate that data at this time.'

    March 7th, 2023 person_outline Judy B.
    Q: This is flavored milk or whole milk?

    A: 'Our orange milk is 100% low heat pasteurized whole milk with flavoring added.'

    February 10th, 2022 person_outline Reetu k.
    Q: Mmmm This was delicious! A creamsicle in a glass!!

    A: Thank you! We are so glad that you enjoyed this!

    April 16th, 2021 person_outline Heather G.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteIf you like creamsicles, you will like this. I like it, my son does not. I order it regularly.format_quote

    February 20th, 2024 person_outline Sandra M
    star star star star star

    format_quoteMy kids absolutely love this milk! A great treat!format_quote

    January 15th, 2024 person_outline Benjamin S
    star star star star star

    format_quoteI need to update my previous review. While I did not like this item my sister has made me aware that she LOVES it. Lol. I will be buying this for her again in the future.format_quote

    May 26th, 2023 person_outline Leslie D
    star_outline star_outline star_outline star_outline star_outline

    format_quoteI was ready to just love this!! All I can say is thank goodness I only ordered half a gallon. I have poured it down the sink. It tasted like medicine.format_quote

    May 23rd, 2023 person_outline Leslie D View Reply
    star star star star star

    format_quoteIt tasted amazing like I was eating a creamsicleformat_quote

    March 7th, 2023 person_outline Matthew R
    star star star star star

    format_quoteThis is amazing! Love all your flavors but this one may top them all!format_quote

    February 10th, 2022 person_outline Sara M.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteI tried this and it was so amazing I ran around the house making everyone try it. They were not impressed, so I left it in a fridge and came back a day later thinking maybe I was just too excite and was wrong.... Nope. It is amazing, tastes like dreamcicles. I really don't know how I'm going to stop myself from getting this every week. :)format_quote

    April 16th, 2021 person_outline Stacie M. View Reply
    star star star star star

    format_quoteOrange Creamsicle Deliciousness! New Horizon Dairy thanks for making this awesome milk so yummy!!format_quote

    March 26th, 2021 person_outline Angela W.
    star star star star star


    March 13th, 2021 person_outline Courtney L.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteI wasn't sure about this, I mean orange milk but it is so good. Creamy and a lovely taste!format_quote

    February 26th, 2021 person_outline Linda W.
    star star star star star

    format_quotereally goodformat_quote

    January 10th, 2021 person_outline joanne h.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteOMG this was soooooooooooo good!! Was better than I imagined!format_quote

    November 5th, 2020 person_outline Shirley G.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteExactly what I was hoping it would taste like. Absolutely delicious!format_quote

    October 13th, 2020 person_outline Lily H.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteTastes just like an orange creamsicle!! format_quote

    June 19th, 2020 person_outline Sondra d.
    Click Here to learn how you can start shopping with friends, discussing products, and sharing your favorites.